11

I have the following dual-screen set up on my Windows 7 PC: [2][1], that means my secondary monitor is on the left side of my primary monitor.

Now I have a dual-screen wallpaper that should stretch across the monitors. I have set it to "Tile" mode.

Problem: The wallpaper invariably starts at [1] (left edge of the image being on the left edge of [1]), and then continues on [2]. It basically splits the wrong way, producing a rather awkward look.

How can I make the wallpaper appear correctly (i.e. left edge of the image being on the left edge of [2])?

P.S.: I am aware that software like UltraMon could work around this by creating tailored wallpapers with flipped halves or whatnot. I consider this a sucky solution. I basically want Windows to get it right by itself. I've actually told it my screen alignment in the Control panel, so it can't be that difficult, can it?

gronostaj
  • 55,965
  • 20
  • 120
  • 179
Tomalak
  • 1,173
  • 5
  • 12
  • 24
  • I have the exact same problem and would love to see a good answer to this. DisplayFusion is a great piece of software, but using it seems like total overkill for this one single feature. – Brant Bobby Aug 26 '10 at 15:26
  • Are both monitors running the same resolution? It could be due to awkward resolutions. For instance, I have one monitor at 1600x1200 and the other at 1280x1024 and I don't think a simple tile would work. – Dillie-O Aug 26 '10 at 22:26
  • You could set your second monitor to the primary monitor and extend to the first one. Is having the start menu on the left screen an option? – default Aug 27 '10 at 08:48
  • Heres another application that can fix it: http://www.howtogeek.com/howto/windows-vista/dual-monitors-use-a-different-wallpaper-on-each-desktop-in-vista-or-xp/ – default Aug 27 '10 at 08:52

6 Answers6

12

As a triple screen monitor user, with a [3][1][2] configuration, I've hit this same problem. Unfortunately, windows actually is that stupid. It defines the left edge of the wallpaper as the left edge of the primary monitor, regardless of how you tell Windows how the monitors are positioned. That screen is only useful for determining how the mouse travels between screens.

I personally use DisplayFusion to correct this unfortunate flaw in the OS.

Ryan Gooler
  • 1,892
  • 13
  • 22
  • Yeah… I guess there is no way denying it. Multi-screen support in Windows 7 sucks. BTW, have you ever tried arranging windows side-by-side with "Aero Snap" in a multi-screen configuration? This is broken as well. – Tomalak Aug 31 '10 at 11:25
  • My main problem with DisplayFusion (which is in all honesty a great bit of software) is that the slideshow feature is only available in the Pro version. Windows 7 has this built-in and I love it. Except for the fact that it doesn't know how to place the wallpaper properly, anyway...*sigh*. Also, DisplayFusion has a ton of other features which I just don't need at all. – Brant Bobby Aug 31 '10 at 17:00
  • Yes, I've been looking into the aero snap thing, but have yet to come up with an answer for it. If you want the slide show feature, you might be able to make a tool that slices and rearranges the wallpaper for you, so you can use the native features. Should be able to do it with a photoshop macro, or a little bit of scripting. – Ryan Gooler Aug 31 '10 at 17:56
  • @Brant: I don't need a wallpaper slideshow - I don't see my wallpaper *that* often anyway… So, I merely use it to do the math and the image manipulation for me when I decide to change the wallpaper. After that I quit the software, because I don't care for the keyboard shortcuts and the other features. – Tomalak Sep 01 '10 at 10:16
  • @Ryan: The thing that makes DisplayFusion sexy (as the wallpaper manipulation software, at least) is that it uses the display configuration from control panel and configured resolutions to do The Right Thing with one click. Windows native support would be nice (and not all that hard to implement) - but writing a script for this is *way* out of scope, for my tastes. – Tomalak Sep 01 '10 at 10:20
  • for snapping windows side-by-side you can use win+left/right, and win+shift+left/right to move the window between monitors – phuclv Oct 23 '13 at 00:43
5

I don't have two monitors but i know a friend that use Dual Monitor Tools. Is a suite of individual apps, you load only the ones you need. The suite currently includes four applications Swap Screen, Dual Wallpaper, DisMon, and Dual Swap. I'm not sure if it is what you need but is free.

Ither
  • 370
  • 2
  • 8
  • 16
  • Regarding custom wallpaper configuration, the Dual Monitor Tools (I've tested release 1.4) are inferior to DisplayFusion (tested: version 3.1.10 free). – Tomalak Aug 31 '10 at 12:04
  • Using this tool now. It's indeed inferiour to UltraMon and DisplayFusion, but those are trialware nowadays. – Jan_V Jun 23 '12 at 14:16
  • 1
    YEEEESSSS!!!! All I wanted to do was have an image span my monitors and this did it without having to buy more shovel-ware! – skub Sep 12 '15 at 00:08
  • That thing is free, is still updated, and does exactly what I need: span a 5760x1080 picture over my 3 monitors in the correct order. It just saves the picture in a new file after cutting the left portion of the image and pasting it to the right (that's if your center screen is your main). It works with folders, it will regenerate the picture every X hour/minute and set it as the background. You can also generate the wallpapers manually, picture per picture (no batch function) and then use the default Windows option. Ressource-wise, it takes a split second and doesn't add lag to my games. – dan Dec 12 '15 at 18:19
2

By stating you want Windows to get it right itself you dismiss both a) custom software and b) the option of taking the 20 seconds to swap the halves of the image in a basic image editor.

I guess your only option left is to hope and wait for Windows 8. There is a reason there's custom software for this problem.

Daniel Beck
  • 109,300
  • 14
  • 287
  • 334
  • Since the two monitors are of different resolution, "swapping the image in 20 seconds" will not work. Some rather cumbersome (for the purpose) math and some lengthy image editor work will be required to make it look right. It's not complicated to do the math, it just plain sucks. – Tomalak Aug 31 '10 at 10:26
  • OK, but that information is not part of your original question. I answered it the only possible way: stating the "sucky" solutions (different resolutions make manual editing only suckier) you dismiss are the only ones you have available. – Daniel Beck Aug 31 '10 at 11:32
  • I deliberately tried to prevent quick "why, just use 3rd party software X"-answers, because I hoped for a "switch hidden registry setting X" answer. Obviously there is no such setting (which I anticipated to some extend, but well…). Anyway, You are right, I should have stated the different resolutions as part of the problem. – Tomalak Aug 31 '10 at 12:12
  • I'd appreciate it if the person downvoting would be so kind to state the reason. If there's just no solution within the given boundaries, an answer stating exactly that is, in fact, an answer. – Daniel Beck Nov 08 '11 at 09:55
  • (It wasn't me, in case you suspect that) – Tomalak Nov 08 '11 at 10:33
  • @Tomalak No I didn't, thanks for the information though; it's unfortunate that as the only other user to comment on this post you got notified. – Daniel Beck Nov 08 '11 at 10:50
  • I'm pretty sure voters are not being notified of new comments to posts they've voted on. This would probably result in inbox overflow. ;) But I guess asking for this on meta would't hurt. – Tomalak Nov 08 '11 at 10:52
  • We are nearly in 2016 and it's still a problem if you are using Windows 7. Yes, @DanielBeck, I'm dismissing the option of taking 20 seconds to swap the halves of my 500 pictures, all 7680x1600 resolution. You may realize that it takes actually more than 20 seconds to do only one picture, even with the proper computer (which I own), and I'm not talking about doing it 500 times (well, there are some ways to do that programatically, but still). The problem with custom softwares is that you will probably need to pay to get a good one, not to say that it's one more process running all the time. – dan Dec 12 '15 at 05:55
  • @dnLL See the previous comments. I answered the question as stated by pointing out that the question backs itself into a corner by dismissing all available options. It's not my fault Windows does (did?) not have this feature built-in. You'll notice that the question dismisses *software like UltraMon* as a *sucky solution*, but then an answer that proposes DisplayFusion was accepted, so clearly there's no good solution within the boundaries set up by the question. – Daniel Beck Dec 12 '15 at 22:12
1

I had this very issue today but rather than downloading a 3rd-Party app I wanted to give this a go see if I could resolve it.

I right-clicked the desktop and selected Screen Resolution then on the dialog window that appears I clicked on the checkbox option labelled "Make this your main display".

I did the above for the primary display and this fixed the scaling problem if you already have set it to the primary display then make the second screen the primary and switch back again.

You should find your background is now properly scaled to the primary monitor and you can then set how the background should scale in the Personalize > Desktop Backgrounds option screen.

Trevor
  • 211
  • 2
  • 3
0

I think the problem begins with your setup and understanding of how Windows works with multiple monitors. I'm not saying it's right or wrong (or that you are), it's just the way it is.

First, Windows needs for your primary monitor to be on the left. Obviously you can switch this around (I've even seen them in the above/below configuration).

Second, based on the first, Windows will only flow left to right.

Now, on to fixing your particular problem.

What you will need to do is take your current dual-screen wallpaper and cut it exactly in half. Then you need to join those two halves BACKWARDS, ie... the left is what you would normally expect on the right, & vice versa.

Now, when you tile, they will show what you have, but since your monitors are set up "backwards" (according to Windows), the wallpaper will appear properly.

If you don't have a program to do your editing with, may I recommend irfanview.com. Or use any of the online offerings. Irfanview is free, easy to use, and a great program. It also has an option to create a Panorama, which makes this all a bit easier, since it will join your two halves back into a whole.

Good luck, God bless, and have fun "being backwards!"

SaxManEric

SaxManEric
  • 9
  • 1
  • My primary monitor has a different resolution than my secondary one. Simply cutting the image in halves and flipping them will not produce visually appealing results. – Tomalak Aug 31 '10 at 10:28
-4

You can use a few windows screen managers and wallpaper managers that add extra functionality to dual screen setups.

DisplayFusion is a good free option.

For a few ££ Ultramon is far better; I think there is a shareware version.

nhinkle
  • 37,198
  • 36
  • 140
  • 177
Fulcanelli
  • 206
  • 2
  • 7